Lending your money: the numbers that matter
What is the real return? Net of fees and defaults
Advertised rates are before bad debts. Enter your own assumptions and compare with a protected savings account.
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent or stored.
Illustrative, one-year view. Defaults tend to rise sharply in a downturn, and you may be unable to sell your loans early.
How spreading your money changes the risk
Runs in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent or stored.
Sources: FCA: peer-to-peer lending
Illustrative: treats defaults as independent. In a downturn many loans can fail together. Peer-to-peer lending is not covered by FSCS deposit protection.
Peer-to-peer lending vs a savings account
P2P lending is often compared with savings, but the risks are very different.
| Bank or building society savings | Peer-to-peer lending | |
|---|---|---|
| FSCS protection | Yes, up to the limit per bank | No |
| Can you lose money? | Not if within protection limits | Yes, if borrowers default or the platform fails |
| Access to money | Instant or fixed term | Often locked in; selling early may not be possible |
| Regulation | PRA and FCA | FCA-authorised platform; investment rules apply |
| Tax-free wrapper | Cash ISA | Innovative Finance ISA |
Sources: FSCS · FCA Financial Services Register
Most retail investors must classify themselves and pass an appropriateness check before investing in P2P.
Four kinds of crowdfunding
| Type | What you get | Regulated by the FCA? | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loan-based (peer-to-peer) | Interest, and your capital back if borrowers repay | Yes | Defaults, platform failure, being unable to exit |
| Investment-based (equity) | Shares in a young company | Yes | Most start-ups fail; shares are hard to sell and rarely pay dividends |
| Donation-based | Nothing: it is a gift | No | Misuse of funds; check the organiser |
| Reward-based | A product or perk | No | The product may arrive late or never |
Sources: FCA: crowdfunding
Six checks before you lend through a platform
- Check authorisationFind the platform on the FCA Register and confirm it has permission to operate an electronic system in relation to lending.
- Read the default dataPlatforms must publish expected and actual default rates. Compare several years, not the best one.
- Understand who you are lending toConsumers, small businesses or property developers carry very different risks.
- Ask how you get outA secondary market only works if another investor wants to buy. You may be locked in.
- Read the wind-down planPlatforms must have arrangements for loans to keep being collected if the platform fails. Several platforms have closed to retail investors.
- Spread and limitDo not put in money you may need, and keep high-risk investments to a small part of your savings.
Sources: FCA: rules for P2P platforms · FCA Register
Red flags in lending and 'bond' offers
- 'Guaranteed', 'secured' or 'fixed' returns well above bank rates.
- The word 'ISA' used to imply safety: an Innovative Finance ISA has no FSCS protection against loan losses.
- A 'provision fund' described as if it were insurance. It can run out.
- Pressure to self-certify as a sophisticated or high-net-worth investor.
- The firm is unauthorised, or claims to be 'registered with' a regulator rather than authorised.
- Mini-bonds or loan notes sold by cold call or social media advert.
Sources: FCA Warning List
Where to check and complain
Lending platform glossary
- Peer-to-peer (P2P) lending
- Lending your money to people or businesses through an online platform, in return for interest.
- Innovative Finance ISA
- An ISA wrapper for P2P loans and some crowdfunding debt. Returns are tax-free but capital is at risk.
- Provision fund
- A pot some platforms keep to cover missed payments. It is discretionary and limited.
- Secondary market
- Where investors sell loan parts to each other before the loan ends.
- Appropriateness test
- Questions a platform must ask to check you understand the risks before you invest.
- Default
- When a borrower stops repaying. Recovery can take years and may be partial.
Lending Platforms: questions and answers
How it works
Is money lent through a peer-to-peer platform protected?
UKGenerally not: peer-to-peer lending is not covered by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme in the way bank deposits are, and you can lose some or all of your money.
Platforms must be authorised by the FCA, but authorisation does not guarantee returns. Treat projected returns as targets, not promises.
Official sources: FSCS – what we cover · FCA Financial Services Register
What should a lending platform disclose before I invest?
UKLook for clear information on who the borrowers are, how loans are assessed, historic default and loss rates, fees, how long your money is tied up and what happens if the platform fails.
If a platform cannot explain how it would wind down its loan book, or reports no defaults at all, ask why. Compare the disclosure with the risk warnings the FCA requires.
Official sources: FCA – investment risks · FCA Financial Services Register
Can I get my money out early?
UKOften only if another investor buys your loans, which may take time or not be possible at all, especially in a downturn.
Check the platform's exit rules and any fees before you invest, and only lend money you can leave in place for the full term.
Official sources: FCA InvestSmart
What are tokenised private-credit products, and how should I check them?
UKUSThey are digital tokens that claim to represent loans or loan funds; the key checks are who the legal issuer is, what assets actually back the token, and whether independent evidence supports the issuer's claims.
Our sister site rwa.ngo checks issuer claims for tokenised real-world assets against original documents and on-chain records.
Official sources: FCA – cryptoassets · SEC – Investor.gov
What is peer-to-peer lending?
UKPeer-to-peer (P2P) lending is when individuals lend money, through an online platform, to people or businesses that borrow it, in return for interest.
It is an investment, not a savings account: you can lose some or all of the money if borrowers default or the platform fails. FSCS protection does not cover losses on P2P loans.
Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · Financial Services Compensation Scheme
How does peer-to-peer lending work?
UKYou deposit money on a platform, which spreads it across loans to borrowers it has assessed; borrowers repay with interest, and the platform takes a fee.
Returns depend on how well the platform assesses borrowers and recovers bad debts. Read the platform's default and recovery figures, its fees and what happens if it closes. Some platforms offer a 'provision fund', which is not a guarantee.
Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · MoneyHelper
What happened to peer-to-peer lending?
UKUSSeveral of the best-known UK and US platforms have stopped offering P2P lending to retail investors, closed or turned into banks, often after tighter rules, the pandemic and rising funding costs.
If a platform you use is winding down, its plan should explain how existing loans will be collected and repaid. Contact the platform and check its updates. Withdrawals may take years.
Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · SEC – Investor.gov
Can you make money with peer-to-peer lending?
UKSome investors have earned more than on savings, but higher rates reflect higher risk, and losses from defaults or platform failure can wipe out returns.
Compare the after-fee, after-default return with a protected savings account. Check how long your money is locked in. Be wary of platforms promising fixed high returns, especially those linked to property or crypto.
Official sources: FCA ScamSmart · MoneyHelper
Does borrowing through a peer-to-peer platform affect my credit score?
UKYes. A loan from a P2P platform is credit like any other loan: the application usually leaves a hard search, and repayments are reported to credit reference agencies.
The platform must be FCA-authorised to arrange consumer loans. Compare the APR and total amount payable with banks and credit unions.
Official sources: ICO – credit reference files · FCA Financial Services Register
What are the pros and cons of peer-to-peer lending?
UKFor lenders, the main advantage is potentially higher interest; the main disadvantages are the risk of losing money, no FSCS protection and limited access to your money.
For borrowers, P2P loans can be competitive but are still regulated credit, so the same checks apply. For both, the platform's financial health matters as much as the borrowers'.
Official sources: Financial Services Compensation Scheme · MoneyHelper
Costs, tax and value
How is peer-to-peer lending taxed in the UK?
UKUSInterest from P2P loans is taxable savings income, but it can be covered by your Personal Savings Allowance or held tax-free in an Innovative Finance ISA.
Some bad debts can be set against P2P interest for tax. In the US, P2P interest is taxable income.
Official sources: GOV.UK – tax on savings interest · GOV.UK – Individual Savings Accounts
Staying safe
How do I spot an investment scam dressed up as lending?
UKUSWarning signs include guaranteed high returns, pressure to invest quickly, unregulated 'bonds' and firms that are not on the FCA register.
Check the FCA warning list and use the contact details on the register, not those in the promotion. In the United States, check investment firms with the SEC and FINRA.
Official sources: FCA ScamSmart · SEC – Investor.gov
Is peer-to-peer lending regulated in the UK?
UKYes. Since 2014, UK platforms that operate P2P lending must be authorised by the FCA, which sets rules on disclosure, risk management and wind-down plans.
Regulation is not a guarantee against losses. P2P agreements are treated as higher-risk 'restricted mass market investments'. If you invest without advice, the platform must check that the investment is appropriate for you, and most investors must certify that they will invest no more than 10% of their net assets.
Official sources: FCA Financial Services Register · FCA ScamSmart
Is peer-to-peer lending safe?
UKIt carries real risk: borrowers can default, the platform can fail, and you may not be able to get your money out when you want.
Spreading money across many loans reduces, but does not remove, the risk. Treat headline rates as targets, not promises, and invest only money you can afford to tie up and potentially lose.
Official sources: FCA ScamSmart · MoneyHelper
In the United States
Is peer-to-peer lending legal in the US?
USYes, but platforms that sell loan notes to the public must register them with the SEC, and some states limit who can invest.
The largest US platform stopped selling notes to retail investors in 2020, and options for individuals are now limited. Check any platform's filings and complaints history on Investor.gov before investing.
Official sources: SEC – Investor.gov · SEC EDGAR – company filings
Official help and where to check
- FCA Financial Services Register — check that a lender, broker or debt firm is authorised
- FCA ScamSmart — warnings about scam firms
- FCA InvestSmart — guidance on investment risk
- SEC – Investor.gov (US) — US investor education and checks
- MoneyHelper — free, impartial guidance backed by government
- StepChange Debt Charity — free debt advice
- National Debtline — free debt advice
- Citizens Advice — free advice on money and consumer problems
- Financial Ombudsman Service — free route for unresolved complaints
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (US) — US consumer credit rules and complaints
The list above contains public bodies and non-profit services only. Any company named elsewhere on this site is mentioned for information only; we have no commercial relationship with any organisation named.
About this site
lending.ngo is a public-interest website of FINANCE TRANSPARENCY CIC, a non-profit community interest company registered in England and Wales (company number 17530096). It belongs to our Programme 2 · Household Costs & Debt. We sell nothing, carry no advertising and take no commission. The company is asset-locked, and its websites and domain names are used only for its community purpose and are not for sale.
About us, our principles and governance · Every source cited on this site · Corrections and right of reply: contact@lending.ngo